AI Making Legal Judgements

Algorithms become the arbiters of determinations about individuals (e.g. government benefits, granting licenses, pre-sentencing and sentencing, granting parole). Whilst AI tools may be used to mitigate human biases and for speed and lower costs of trials, there is evidence that it may enforce biases by using characteristics such as postcode or social economic level as a proxy for ethnicity. 

The use of commercial AI tools such speech recognition – which have been shown to be less reliable for non-white speakers – can actively harm some groups when criminal justice agencies use them to transcribe courtroom proceedings.

Filter resources by type or complexity

Measuring racial discrimination in algorithms

Measuring racial discrimination in algorithms

Measuring racial discrimination in algorithmsThere is growing concern that the rise of algorithmic decision-making can lead to discrimination against legally protected groups, but measuring such algorithmic discrimination is often hampered…

Read More
The danger of predictive algorithms in criminal justice

The danger of predictive algorithms in criminal justice

Dartmouth professor Dr. Hany Farid reverse engineers the inherent dangers and potential biases of recommendations engines built to mete out justice in today’s criminal justice system. In this video, he…

Read More
How AI Could Reinforce Biases In The Criminal Justice System

How AI Could Reinforce Biases In The Criminal Justice System

Whilst some believe AI will increase police and sentencing objectivity, others fear it will exacerbate bias. For example, the over-policing of minority communities in the past has generated a disproportionate…

Read More
The danger of predictive algorithms in criminal justice

The danger of predictive algorithms in criminal justice

adh_algorithms.pdfShared with Dropbox A study on the discriminatory impact of algorithms in pre-trial bail decisions.

Read More
Racial disparities in automated speech recognition

Racial disparities in automated speech recognition

Racial disparities in automated speech recognitionAutomated speech recognition (ASR) systems are now used in a variety of applications to convert spoken language to text, from virtual assistants, to closed captioning,…

Read More
Adjudicating by Algorithm, Regulating by Robot

Adjudicating by Algorithm, Regulating by Robot

Adjudicating by Algorithm, Regulating by RobotSophisticated computational techniques, known as machine-learning algorithms, increasingly underpin advances in business practices, from investment banking to product marketing and self-driving cars. Machine learning—the foundation…

Read More
Artificial intelligence in the courtroom

Artificial intelligence in the courtroom

Artificial intelligence in the courtroomThe impact of AI on litigation. The current use of AI in reviewing documents, predicting outcome of cases and predicting success rates for lawyers. This article…

Read More
How AI is impacting the UK’s legal sector

How AI is impacting the UK’s legal sector

How AI is Being Used in the UK’s Legal SectorWe examine the impact of artificial intelligence on the UK’s legal sector

Read More
Six ways the legal sector is using AI right now

Six ways the legal sector is using AI right now

Six ways the legal sector is using AI right nowLaw Society partner and equity crowdfunding platfrom Seedrs explains how developments within AI are taking law firms and solicitors to the…

Read More

Actions you can take

Other topics in this area